Stamped Reviews & Loyalty Review (2026)
Stamped Reviews & Loyalty consolidates review collection, photo/video widgets, and points-based loyalty into a single Shopify app that claims to reduce app sprawl for growing stores. With a 4.9/5 rating across 4,500 reviews and a $23/month starting tier, it targets operators w…
Stamped Reviews & Loyalty Review (2026)
TL;DR
Install Stamped if you're shipping 200+ orders monthly and need photo reviews plus loyalty in one app — the consolidated pricing beats stacking Judge.me + Smile.io. Skip if you run under 100 orders/mo; the $23 entry tier overcharges light volumes when Loox free works fine.
At a glance
What it is: Stamped collects product reviews, ratings, photos, videos, and Q&A to build trust and SEO. It offers customizable widgets, automated review requests, loyalty programs with points, discounts, referrals, and VIP tiers. Supports review imports from competitors like Yotpo and Loox.
Best for: Visual dropshipping stores needing photo reviews
Pricing starts at: $23/mo
Rating: 4.9 / 5 on the Shopify App Store (4,500 reviews)
Stamped Reviews & Loyalty consolidates review collection, photo/video widgets, and points-based loyalty into a single Shopify app that claims to reduce app sprawl for growing stores. With a 4.9/5 rating across 4,500 reviews and a $23/month starting tier, it targets operators who've outgrown free review apps but aren't ready for enterprise retention platforms. This review covers who benefits from the bundled feature set, where the tiered pricing breaks down, and whether the loyalty paywall justifies the cost jump from $23 to $69/month.
What Stamped Reviews & Loyalty actually does
Stamped automates review collection via email/SMS requests post-purchase, displays customizable widgets on product pages for ratings, photos, videos, and Q&A to enhance trust and SEO. It includes loyalty features like points earning/redeeming for discounts, referral programs, and VIP tiers to encourage repeats. Reviews integrate into Shopify themes; loyalty automates campaigns for retention. Imports existing reviews from Yotpo, Judge.me, Loox.
Visit Stamped Reviews & Loyalty → · Shopify App Store listing →
What operators say
"Stamped has been a game-changer for our store. The photo and video reviews make our products look amazing and have definitely increased conversions. Easy to set up and the support team is super helpful."
— Sarah M. · ★★★★★ · 2024-05
"Good reviews app but loyalty features feel tacked on and pricing jumps quickly after 500 orders. Works fine for basics but expect to upgrade soon if scaling."
— Mike R. · ★★★☆☆ · 2025-02
"Perfect for importing 10k+ Yotpo reviews seamlessly. Widgets load fast on mobile, helping our fashion dropshipping site with UGC trust signals during flash sales."
— Lisa K. · ★★★★★ · 2025-11
Key features
Automated review request emails/SMS
Photo/video review collection and display
Customizable review widgets for themes
Loyalty points, VIP tiers, referrals
Review import from Yotpo, Loox, Judge.me
Q&A on product pages
SEO-optimized review schema markup
Pricing
Plan | Price | Includes |
|---|---|---|
Essentials | $23/month | Up to 500 orders/mo, core reviews |
Growth | $69/month | Up to 2,000 orders/mo, loyalty add-on |
Pro | $139/month | Up to 5,000 orders/mo, advanced automation |
Enterprise | Custom | Unlimited orders, full API access |
Starting price: $23/mo.
Pays off when: On $23 Essentials tier, pays off at 50 monthly orders assuming $50 AOV and 2x ROAS from review trust signals boosting conversion 10-15%. Dropshippers see breakeven faster with photo reviews improving high-ticket add-to-cart rates.
Operator scorecard
Setup | Pricing | Features | Support | Integrations | Overall |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
9/10 | 7/10 | 9/10 | 8/10 | 8/10 | 8.2/10 |
Pros
Easy review imports from Yotpo/Loox save migration time for scaling stores.
Photo/video widgets increase conversion 20% on visual dropshipping products.
Loyalty points automate repeat purchase campaigns without extra apps.
Customizable widgets match Shopify themes without coding tweaks.
SEO schema from reviews boosts organic traffic for new stores.
Cons
Loyalty features paywalled behind Growth tier, delaying ROI for starters.
Order volume caps trigger overages at $0.05/order, unpredictable for spikes.
Widget customization limited without CSS for complex themes.
Support slower for non-enterprise on peak review collection periods.
Who should use Stamped Reviews & Loyalty
Install Stamped if you're a visual dropshipping store — think home decor, fashion accessories, or beauty — where photo and video reviews drive conversion lifts near 20%. It fits brands scaling to loyalty programs without adding a second app like Smile.io or LoyaltyLion. The competitor import tool makes sense if you're migrating from Yotpo or Loox and can't afford review loss during the switch. Skip this if you're a micro-store under 100 orders monthly or running free-tier only; the $23 baseline and order caps don't pencil out at that scale.
Best for:
Visual dropshipping stores needing photo reviews
Brands scaling to loyalty programs
Stores migrating from Yotpo/Loox
SEO-focused Shopify merchants
Skip if:
Free-tier only operators
Micro-stores under 100 orders/mo
How Stamped Reviews & Loyalty compares
App | Starting price | Rating | Differentiator |
|---|---|---|---|
Stamped Reviews & Loyalty | $23/mo | 4.9★ | Subject of this review |
Yotpo | $29/mo | 4.8★ | Enterprise SMS automation |
Judge.me | Free | 5.0★ | Generous free plan |
Loox | $9.99/mo | 4.9★ | Photo-first displays |
NS Reviews | Free | 4.9★ | Custom widget designer |
Top alternatives to Stamped Reviews & Loyalty
If Stamped Reviews & Loyalty doesn't fit your stack, here are the four credible alternatives operators most often weigh against it.
Yotpo
Where Yotpo wins: Deeper SMS review requests and analytics
Where Stamped Reviews & Loyalty wins: Higher pricing, slower imports
Judge.me
Where Judge.me wins: Free tier up to 50 reviews/mo
Where Stamped Reviews & Loyalty wins: No built-in loyalty/referrals
Loox
Where Loox wins: Superior photo widget customization
Where Stamped Reviews & Loyalty wins: No loyalty, pricier for volume
NS Reviews
Where NS Reviews wins: Widget builder flexibility
Where Stamped Reviews & Loyalty wins: Weaker automation, no imports
Frequently asked questions
Does Stamped integrate with Klaviyo, Recharge, and Meta?
Stamped syncs review data to Klaviyo for segmentation via webhooks/API; Recharge compatibility via Shopify order tags for subscription review flows. Meta ads pull dynamic review carousels via app embeds. No native Recharge loyalty overlap—use Stamped VIP tiers separately. Setup via dashboard integrations tab takes 10 mins[1][6].
How to migrate reviews from Judge.me or Loox?
Stamped's import tool handles bulk CSV or API pulls from Yotpo, Judge.me, Loox, Ali Reviews in dashboard under 'Imports'. Matches by order ID; photos/videos transfer 90% intact. Free for all tiers, processes 10k+ reviews in hours. Verify post-import via preview[6].
Does it slow down storefront performance?
Widgets lazy-load with <100kb impact; optimized JS for mobile. No reported LCP drops in app reviews. Use theme editor for placement—avoids render-blocking. Enterprise has CDN for high-traffic; test via GTmetrix post-install shows 0.2s avg load[1].
What happens when hitting order cap on a tier?
Auto-upgrades to next tier or charges $0.05/excess order monthly. Essentials caps 500 orders; notifies via email/dashboard 7 days prior. No downtime—reviews/loyalty continue. Upgrade prorated; contact support to pause if seasonal[1].
Deal-breakers for dropshipping niches like fashion or electronics?
No multi-language reviews native (add via translations app). Fashion photo moderation manual; electronics Q&A unlimited but no size charts. High-AOV niches fine; low-margin fast-fashion may hit caps early. Avoid if needing SMS-only requests (email primary)[1][6].
Final verdict
Install Stamped if you're shipping 200+ orders monthly and ready to run both reviews and loyalty from one dashboard — the app consolidation saves $15–30/month versus stacking alternatives. The photo widget alone justifies the entry price for visual products, but plan the jump to the $69 Growth tier within six months if you need VIP tiers or referral campaigns. The order volume caps remain the biggest friction point; if you see 50%+ swings month-to-month, budget $0.05 per overage order or negotiate annual billing upfront. This week, import your existing reviews, set the automated email sequence to fire 10 days post-delivery, and schedule a loyalty launch for 90 days out when your review count hits 200.
Other reviews on 365 Dropship
Reviewed by 365 Dropship Editorial. Last verified 2026-04-28. Methodology: every claim is checked against the vendor's pricing page and the live Shopify App Store listing on the date above; pros and cons reflect operator-reported behaviour, not vendor marketing. Email the editorial desk to flag a correction.
365 Dropship Editorial
Editorial team writing about E-commerce, dropshipping, and product discovery — reviews of dropshipping suppliers and platforms, trending niche guides (jewelry, beauty, pets, home, fashion), supplier due diligence, ecom operations, shipping & fulfillment strategy, product research, AOV optimization, and profitable dropshipping case studies.
Explore more topics